OK. I’mma be clear, here. I think this is sum bullshit, and I don’t do it in my relationships, BUT people do for their own reasons, and I’m going to explore this, so you have examples of how “No” can be used that is not actually “No.”
(Feels very “Depends on what your definition of “is” is, to me, but you do you…)
NO! Means Yes!
In Polish, “No” spelled and pronounced exactly that way is an affirmative response. It’s used less often as a direct response:
“Will you kink with me?”
“No.” <— Not really the right grammar, more likely to use “Tak,” (yes), or “Nie” (no).
“I love to kink!”
“No,” (yeah) or “No to dobra,” (yeah, it’s good).
Polish speakers use “no” in conversation to show they are listening, as English speakers might use “Yeah,” “Sure,” “Uh huh,” or “Go on…”
NO! Means “I’m being playful!”
Some people like to play the brat in their relationships (whether power exchange or not). In those situations, “No” might mean “Make me,” or “Chase me through the house growling, while I giggle until you catch me and have your naughty, naughty way with me.”
In a case like this, I would suggest that you have a word that really doesn’t fit into most situations naturally that can be used to mean “No, 100%, absolutely,” so if there is confusion or an actual hard “no” needs to be uttered, that word can stand in it’s place.
Meatloaf (I’ll do anything for love, but I won’t do that.)
When something like this is negotiated and put into place in a relationship or a scene, it’s often called a safeword.
All of these are safewords I’ve encountered in my time in kink.
NO! Means “Oh fudgesicles, this hurts!”
In some cases, during intense kinky play, the word that comes out of people’s mouth is “No.”
It can be used in those cases as a sort of exclamation, even an utterance of “I don’t like that, don’t want it, but will also quite possibly enjoy how I feel when it happens.”
In mindgames and edge play, the “No” could be a part of the scene: “Convince me you don’t want this, or I will stop the scene,” when it’s something you do very much want, and hope will be part of the continued scene.
Again, in cases like this, a safeword is used.
Safewords are nice, because you really only have to agree to them once (per scene or per relationship, depending on your dynamics), and then you say “No” all you want without repercussions, until the scene, dynamic, or relationship ends or you safe word out.
The following not-No is not negotiated, and as-such, TO ME erode the confidence that anyone can have in the word “no” in their relationships and communication.
My answer is simple.
I take people at their word. If they say no, I take the no.
I would prefer to be wrong some of the time by taking a “No” to mean “No,” than to be wrong by thinking it meant something else. And frankly, if someone says “No” to me (without prior negotiation) and does not mean “No,” I’m going to bet they will not be a good match to me in communication styles and relating.
People say things like, “People say ‘No,’ and mean ‘Yes,’ or ‘Yes,’ and mean ‘No.’ People play word games.”
Yes, they do.
However, I can choose to engage in those games or not. And I choose not.
So, moving forward…
NO! Means “Prove that you want it.”
Some people use “No” as a way to gauge your desire and persistence.
“If you really wanted [fill-in-theblank], you’d have tried harder.”
I don’t play this game, and I don’t accept people playing this game with me. If I want something, I’ll say so, and give you a chance to consent or not. I expect the same in return.
My “No” is absolute. I made that clear in my previous writing.
In other words, if you interact with me, you can rest assured that my “No” means “No,” if I choose to not qualify or add explanation that invites further discussion.
Obviously, not everyone works this way
YOUR “No” is allowed to mean anything you want it to.
“Banana” can mean no. Or yes. Or “remember that time that we were at the zoo, and that money made a rude gesture with it’s banana?”
OF COURSE, two people (or more) can agree to something different.
And high high-context language interactions.
That does not change the default.
And I hope that when it doesn’t mean “No, end of story,” that you are clear about that, and when it does mean “No, end of story,” you don’t hold it against anyone who does not take it as a final “no,” if you choose to not be consistent with your meanings.
What are your thoughts?
Do you negotiate a safeword for play and relating, so that you can say “No” and not mean it? Or possibly put other agreements into place?
Do you keep YOUR “No” sacrosanct?
Do you think that language is far more flexible than I am portraying it, and I’m a stick in the mud? (I’m 100% OK with that.)